Our recipe for honey mustard sauce is perfect for dipping everything from chicken nuggets to your favorite roasted veggies. It is sweet and tangy, with perfect consistency. Not too thick, but it will coat whatever your dipping pleasure.
The secret to this sauce is using the right type of mustard and we have broken all the details down for you. Plus we love that this recipe is gluten free and dairy free.
Please read the entire post for tips and tricks to ensure a perfect recipe every time. And don't forget to tag @peelwithzeal on Instagram so we can admire your creation!
This post may include affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.
🧾Ingredients
Just three ingredients are needed for this easy honey mustard recipe! With so few ingredients it is important to use high-quality items.
- Brown mustard
- Mayonnaise
- Raw honey
Check the ingredient label on your mayo. If you don't see lemon juice as an ingredient we recommend adding a squeeze of lemon juice. It really does make a difference!
📋 The Best Mustard
The key to any honey mustard sauce is of course the mustard. With so many options it can be hard to know where to start. What is the best mustard to use when making honey mustard?
Brown stadium-style mustard is the best for honey mustard sauces. It has a complex but not overwhelming flavor and smooth consistency for easy blending.
Our overall favorite brand was Cleveland's Authentic Stadium Mustard. If you can't this in your area Gulden's Brown Mustard was a close second.
After trying multiple mustards we feel pretty strongly about this. But in case you are wondering here is how the competition broke down.
- Yellow Mustard- The watery consistency made it a tad too thin and the vinegar taste was too strong.
- Dijon Mustard- This was our runner up. It has a good, but less complex flavor.
- Stadium Mustard- Our clear winner.
- Grainy or Country Style- The texture was a bit off for dipping. We like to reserve grainy mustards for salad dressings.
We do not recommend using dried mustards in this, of any other honey mustard dip recipe.
⏲️Instructions
This recipe for homemade honey mustard could not be easier. Simply mix all your ingredients in a small bowl until well combined. There is no need for a food processor or blender. A whisk or spoon and a small bowl are sufficient.
You can make your honey mustard sauce in advance. Store in the fridge in an airtight container for up to 10 days.
💭 Variations
Garlic Honey Mustard
Garlic honey mustard sauce can be made two ways. The first is by substituting the honey with fermented garlic honey While this is our favorite version, a much easier way is to add 2 cloves of smashed roasted garlic.
Raw garlic is not recommended for this recipe, it is too sharp and competes with the mustard flavors.
Spicy Honey Mustard
Again, a hot honey mustard sauce can be achieved through one or two methods. First, you can substitute the honey with hot honey Or, my preferred method is to simply add ¼ teaspoon of dried cayenne pepper.
While adding hot sauce to the recipe can be tempting the results ranged from wonderful or downright horrendous. It really depended on the mustard and the hot sauce combo. I find the gentle heat of cayenne pepper to always be a winner. You can scale back or up the pepper for your desired heat level.
🥗More Easy Sauce Recipes
Looking for more easy sauce recipes? First off, we have a list of seven more no-cook sauce recipes that just take minutes to make.
But we didn't stop there. I do not like plain food and condiments are my jam. Here are few more sauce recipes we suggest your try.
Cucumber Chutney
Poppy Seed Dressing (Sugar Free)
Chamoy Sauce
If you enjoyed this recipe, please leave us a rating or a comment. It helps other wonderful people connect with our food.
📖 Recipe
Honey Mustard Sauce
Equipment
Ingredients
- ¼ cup brown mustard
- 2 tablespoon raw honey
- ½ cup mayonnaise
Instructions
- Place all ingredients in a small bowl and whisk until smooth. Taste for sweetness and add additional honey, if needed.
- Serve immediately or store in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 10 days
Notes
- Garlic Honey Mustard
- Substitute the honey with fermented garlic honey OR add 2 cloves of smashed roasted garlic.
- Raw garlic is not recommended for this recipe.
- Spicy Honey Mustard
- Substitute the honey with hot honey OR add ¼ teaspoon of dried cayenne pepper.
Toni says
This was a huge hit at my house! A new staple sauce!
Mary says
We're big mustard fans here, and this sauce is a winner! Not too sweet and not too overpowering, just delicious!
Beth says
My daughter is going to love this recipe! I can't wait to give this a try! Looks so delicious!
Jen says
My boys are obsessed with dips and I didn't realize how easy it was to make your own. We're going to try your original recipe tonight but next time will use your tip about adding garlic for next time. Yum!
Melissa says
Thank you. I don't think I realized how simple this is to make yourself!